Asking the right questions is key to getting the correct answers.
Structural engineering is not simply a mechanistic process, but rather discipline that requires an understanding of the interaction of human expectations with the hard realities of science.
The interaction of loads and strengths in the context of human expectations is the basis of the Structural #PerformanceRequirements of #NCC2025 .
But it must be remembered that serviceability considerations are beyond the scope of NCC2025 and rely on the experience of the structural engineer.
This requires practical experience. AI can assist, but it cannot replace the professionalism of an experienced engineer.
Visit https://RodJohnston.com.au
Read #QueensPawnToD4 by #RodJohnston
#StructuralEngineering
Below is an informative article on this subject by Mostafa-El-Mogy, Structural Engineering Educator & Consultant | Co-Founder, Structural Engineering Basics | High-Rise & Complex Structures Specialist | Helping Professionals Speak the Language of Structure
Only three questions really matter in structural analysis. And the answers reveal what every beam is hiding. Pick any point along a beam (see the figure). As engineers, we’re always trying to answer the same three things: 1️⃣ What is the Shear Force (V)? At any section, shear is the resultant vertical force acting there. Think of it like a pair of scissors trying to slice through the beam. Under a uniformly distributed load (w), shear changes linearly At a point load (P), shear jumps instantly Exactly what the diagram shows. 2️⃣ What is the Bending Moment (M)? This is the rotational effect at that point—the thing that makes the beam curve. Bending stretches one side of the beam in tension and squeezes the other in compression. For a typical floor beam (sagging), the bottom is in tension, and the top is in compression. Switch to a cantilever? Everything flips (hogging near the support). 3️⃣ What is the Axial Force (N)? For most horizontal beams under gravity loads, this is often small enough to ignore. But not always. A beam that’s heavily restrained can develop significant axial forces due to temperature changes or lateral loads—and ignoring that can be dangerous. But there’s a 4️⃣th check that many people miss 📉 What is the deflection under service loads? A beamcan pass every strength check and still fail in service. Because a beam can be perfectly safe in strength design… and still: → Crack finishes → Damage partitions → Feel bouncy to occupants That’s why we check deflection limits (L/360, L/480, etc.) under service loads, not ultimate loads. 👉These answers control everything: 🔹Beam size (depth & stiffness) 🔹Material choice (steel, concrete, timber…) 🔹Reinforcement detailing (how much steel, and where) But none of this works if you get the loads wrong first.🛑 – Dead – Live – Wind – Seismic They don’t just add up—they interact and combine. Structural engineering isn’t about complex math. It’s about asking the right questions… in the right order… with the right inputs. 👇 Comment “GUIDE” and I’ll send you our free Ultimate Guide to Structural Engineering Basics.… more
Be the first to commentComme
